GOLEMArchitecture·Art·Design

05.l.2How can a museum compare the carbon impacts of two exhibition designs?

A museum comparing the carbon impacts of two designs needs both estimates to cover the same exhibition brief and period of use. List the emissions sources you can estimate for both, including material quantities, fabrication, transport, operations and the destination of the display after closing. Record exclusions consistently and keep missing information visible in the comparison.

Test the choices that could change the result

The Design Museum’s account of Waste Age describes an environmental audit tied to an actual exhibition. Its guidance provides a precedent for using project data to inform design. The Gallery Climate Coalition’s art fair toolkit extends the discussion to temporary venues and their operations. For a museum comparing two proposals, ask which parts of each will be new, where they are made and which return trips are already agreed. Use the same assumptions for the length of the exhibition and the works being carried. Design Museum, Working to make change Gallery Climate Coalition, Art Fair Toolkit

A table can show each source of emissions beside the data used to estimate it, with a range where quantities or routes are uncertain. If one proposal depends on reuse, compare the outcome with and without the documented next use, applying a consistent accounting approach. Ask the team to update the calculation from orders and actual deliveries, and record the differences after dismantling.

The published accounts of the Broken Hearts Bazaar describe timber kiosks and spices used on their exterior. In KHAMSA, Ariel André relates the smell to how someone might first encounter the structures. A reuse or carbon comparison can keep the supporting material and the finish as separate entries, with a destination and an expected refresh for each. That gives the client a way to include relocation as well as initial fabrication. The costs can be specified in the first exhibition budget before the design is fixed. KHAMSA, Against Good Taste, a conversation with Ariel André Built Current, GOLEM’s scented timber kiosks in Bukhara Ariel André, architecture beyond the human, designboom essay reproduced by Architectural Wise