GOLEMArchitecture·Art·Design

08.e.2When can a furniture screen improve speech privacy in a shared room?

A furniture screen can reduce direct speech transmission between nearby seated positions when the panel interrupts the path from the speaker to the listener and the room limits reflected sound. Draw the talker and the affected listener in section at the proposed desks. If occupants regularly stand or turn toward an aisle to speak, include those positions. Reserve a separate enclosed place for conversations that require confidentiality. Set the criterion with the acoustician in the location people actually use. A quieter voice can still distract if its words remain intelligible.

A cut through the workstation

J. S. Bradley’s National Research Council Canada paper used a sound-propagation model to compare the influence of features in a conventional open-plan office. Ceiling absorption, partial-height panel height, and workstation plan size had the strongest influence in that model. The ceiling matters because sound can travel over the screen and reflect down to the next desk. A panel with an absorbent face and an interruption of the direct sound path address different aspects of the problem. Confirm both with the acoustician before choosing a panel that is sold mainly for its fabric finish. J. S. Bradley, The Acoustical Design of Conventional Open Plan Offices, 2003

French workplace research institute INRS describes absorbent and insulating desk separation over 1.40 meters from the floor in a specific example involving frequent conversations or concentration. The guidance includes protection between people who sit side by side. Treat the height as part of that example. Establish the eye line and speech path from the actual chairs in the project. A screen fixed behind a desk may address someone directly opposite while leaving a diagonal path around its edge to a neighbor with the same sensitivity to speech. INRS, Environnement sonore en bureaux ouverts, ED 6402

A client can start with the paths that generate complaints. A first plan might show a telephone desk alongside a shared reading table. Draw the telephone user's seat and where that person faces while speaking. Mark how the table is reached and the seat a reader moves to when disturbed. A short return panel, a turn in the desk, or a shift in the call position can change the route of sound without screening the view from the rest of the table. Leave the final decision open until the occupied area and the reflected paths have been examined together.

Seung-Min Lee and Chan-Hoon Haan tested four workstation arrangements with 1.5-meter partitions in a 2024 open-office field experiment. The face-to-face layout produced the longest distraction distances of those tested. Spatial speech decay and speech level at four meters received similar grades across the layouts, while the distraction-distance result separated them. The experiment was conducted with background noise at or below 30 dB(A). Use it to decide which listening positions and metrics to ask for. Transfer the measurement method to the new project and establish the actual room conditions before drawing a performance conclusion. Seung-Min Lee and Chan-Hoon Haan, Influence of Partition Layouts on Speech Privacy, Heliyon, 2024

Read the room and product reports separately

ISO 3382-3:2022 describes measurements in an unoccupied open-plan office under a single-talker condition, with quantities related to spatial speech decay. It gives the client and acoustician a shared way to discuss sound through the room. A result from an unrelated office has a different ceiling, layout, and background. Ask what the acoustic assessment covers and where receivers will be located before calling the screen a privacy measure. ISO 3382-3:2022, Open plan offices

ISO 23351-1:2020 is a laboratory method for comparing speech level reduction of complete furniture ensembles or enclosures. Its published scope excludes single workstation components “such as a screen.” When a dealer submits a result, request a drawing of the tested product. Find its returns and openings and check that the report covers the piece being purchased. If the project also considers a small booth, compare booths tested on the same basis and let the acoustician evaluate how the booth sits in the actual room. ISO 23351-1:2020, Furniture ensembles and enclosures

A prototype can be a pair of workstations with real chairs, a plausible speech source, the proposed screen and a nearby position at the end of the screen. Mark one receiving point across the proposed partition and a second around its end by the aisle. Compare before and after from the same speaking position, at the same source level, with the same background conditions at each point. Record whose desk benefits and whose receives speech around the edge. Ask staff to check desk access and visibility while the acoustician checks sound. Keep the record at hand when a subsequent package changes the ceiling or moves the workstation. Those are reasons to reopen the acoustic assessment before ordering all the panels.