GOLEMArchitecture·Art·Design

10.a.1How do you choose an architect for a luxury flagship store or cultural venue?

For a brand weighing up a flagship lease, the first question is whether the premises suit the way the store will trade. For a cultural venue adding public rooms, the question may be which parts can stay open while work goes on. With the same information about the site and its operation, each architect can explain what their team would check, what the first drawing would show, and what the client could decide from it.

Ask the people who will lead the work

An interview should include the proposed project lead. The client can pick one built job in the shortlist and ask them to talk through a change their client made after a drawing review, survey, or mock-up. A candidate should be able to explain who drew the original proposal, what was changed, and who examined the cost and schedule. The client can request two references who can discuss the practice’s role in a comparable decision. The AIA B305 qualification statement collects information about licenses, people, services, and consultants that an owner can use as a starting point. A candidate should be able to explain which of the people identified will be available for your schedule. AIA Contract Documents, B305 Architect’s Qualification Statement

For the Diriyah Biennale Foundation’s Public Programs Building, Ariel André and GOLEM worked within a former warehouse previously converted by Bricklab. SceneHome records André’s intention of “making each new intervention clearly legible while preserving the building’s successive lives.” Ask a candidate which existing conditions they would first survey, what they would retain, and which constraints could rule out a preferred site. Then look for that judgment in the proposal, where the estimated cost and decisions about retaining existing work meet. Serag Heiba, Diriyah Biennale Gets a Permanent Home in a Converted Warehouse, SceneHome

Price the first decision separately

Before comparing offers, define the output of feasibility. A landlord’s plan may need a measured survey before the team can tell whether the site works. A programmed foyer may need opening and closing diagrams with staff positions before a cultural client knows what it can afford to operate. The appointment can establish what the feasibility package will contain. Cost assumptions, parties to consult, and unknowns are part of the deliverable. A candidate should be able to explain whether you can use the survey and report if the later design scope changes. The client can put the scope of that work and responsibility for each check in writing. The RIBA Plan of Work is useful for identifying exchanges at project stages. France’s Ordre des architectes explains its own context for an agreed appointment. RIBA Plan of Work Ordre des architectes, Le contrat avec votre client

Set a stopping point for the first commission

An owner deciding between two premises may need measured information about the entrance, a plan that includes stock, and a dated schedule of discussions with the landlord and local team. The corresponding study for a cultural institution may start with a calendar of activities, which rooms can operate independently, and the condition of the existing structure. The appointment can set the same fee basis for all candidates and ask them what the proposed survey, report, or sketch will allow the owner to rule in or out. If you appoint a team for the study, identify when you can stop and who may use the material.

Once the teams have offered a scope, compare two precedents in detail. If a candidate shows one building where they were lead architect and another where they joined as a design consultant, ask how the scope and team changed between those appointments. The client can compare their examples with the AIA qualification statement’s reference to the people and consultants expected to take part. Then ask for the billable time of the proposed project lead and which work the practice expects to subcontract. The client can let an operator or past client describe a difficult handover, and see how the team names the decision and the person who owned it. AIA Contract Documents, B305 Architect’s Qualification Statement

A one-page comparison can record one issue that may rule out the site, one drawing each practice proposes to produce, and the cost assumption that would most affect the budget. Attach the record to the study appointment, with a date on which the client will decide how to proceed.

Before you ask for a complete fee, return the site report to the people who can act on it. The client can have the property adviser confirm when the decision to commit will be taken. The proposed lead can mark where survey access is still needed and identify which observation would change the decision. A client who is weighing two sites needs a comparison on equal assumptions. A client who has already bought a building needs a scope for resolving the most difficult constraint while the brief can still change. The client can tell the architect which decision will follow the report. A candidate can provide a presentation to that decision-maker and a copy of the drawings they can read after the meeting.

When you have a candidate site, provide the lease or program constraints and the next decision date for a first review with Ariel André, GOLEM.

A shortlist can use one piece of evidence that all candidates have had the same opportunity to provide. The RAIC’s Canadian qualifications-based selection guidance and templates set out how a client can define the project, interview and negotiate. The United Kingdom Architects Registration Board checklist addresses the scope and working relationship of an appointment from a different jurisdiction. In a flagship or cultural venue, a candidate can show how their current team would use one feasibility drawing to answer a lease or programming decision. The commissioning body can fit that exercise into whatever selection rules apply at the site. The brand can put the interview exercise into the brief for its first flagship. Royal Architectural Institute of Canada, qualifications-based selection Royal Architectural Institute of Canada, QBS templates Architects Registration Board, before hiring an architect