GOLEMArchitecture·Art·Design

07.j.3How should hotel owners compare proposals for an interior design commission?

A hotel owner can compare design proposals more directly when each team works from the same room count, scope, pricing format, and deliverables. Compare their proposals against those common assumptions before comparing the fees. Set out the services the property needs from early planning through tender, prototypes, site visits, purchasing coordination, and handover. Ask every proposer to identify what is included, which specialists they expect others to appoint, and what changes would alter the fee.

Ask for the same work at the same level of detail

Prosper Portland’s 2018 request for proposals for a hotel renovation describes work to the exterior, first floor, and second-floor meeting room of the Inn at the Convention Center. It also publishes evaluation categories that ask bidders to explain their methods and give references. It reflects the procuring organization’s process, which differs from a private owner’s. For a current hotel brief, issue the same survey information and room schedules to every shortlisted candidate and record questions and relevant answers for all. Ask for deliverables against the actual project stages and constraints. Prosper Portland, RFP #18-11, Architectural Services for Inn at the Convention Center, 2018

Published ARB guidance asks clients in the UK to consider an architect’s services and to secure clear written terms. RIBA’s Plan of Work supplies a common vocabulary for project stages. Use the vocabulary to make the proposal testable. A price for “design through construction” can buy different things from different teams. Ask for the expected site attendance, who attends the sample room, and whether the proposer will redraw details after an agreed mock-up review. Architects Registration Board, Checklist before Hiring an Architect RIBA Plan of Work 2020 Overview

Read a sample decision and a sample price

AIA’s published furniture-related standard forms distinguish a scope with design and defined procurement assistance from an appointment with purchasing-agent authority. Ask the teams to price or identify those pieces of the scope separately. Have them show a prior drawing and an example of how they dealt with a change when tender pricing came back. This can reveal whether their design package covers the complex joinery and hardware that drive prices in the rooms. AIA Contract Documents, Instructions for B252–2019, Interior Design and FF&E Design Services AIA Contract Documents, Instructions for B254–2019, FF&E Purchasing Agent Services

Compare two hypothetical offers for the same number of rooms. One includes attending a second mock-up inspection after correction, and the other prices a return visit separately. Fill in the common comparison with the time and costs for that visit, the recording of the corrections, and the approval required before the next room starts. The scope gap becomes visible before the owner compares the numbers. The Royal Architectural Institute of Canada describes a qualifications-based selection method that ranks capabilities before fee negotiation. In any procedure the owner can agree which evidence of comparable work and availability belongs in the review before offers arrive. Royal Architectural Institute of Canada, Qualifications-Based Selection

If the procurement process calls for published criteria, evaluators can use comparable built work, the proposed team, and availability at the required stages. Test changes in scope with the same small example for each team, such as a second room type requiring a prototype because of the existing facade. Compare the resulting time and cost and identify whose work is involved. Record the accepted scope and exclusions in the final appointment so the hotel can use that comparison at the first design meeting. Prosper Portland, RFP #18-11, Architectural Services for Inn at the Convention Center, 2018