GOLEMArchitecture·Art·Design

07.b.3Where should a hotel draw the boundary between its public lobby and guest floors?

A hotel’s public lobby can extend as far as the first point where someone needs permission to access a particular room. Visitors should be able to reach the café, event room, or toilets using the public route. Guests should be able to reach guest elevators without being sent back through the bar. Mark an after-hours line as well as the daytime line. The night receptionist needs to operate it with the staff and doors actually available.

Draw who can go where during ordinary service

At Ace Hotel Kyoto, the operator and architect describe a hotel made from the former Kyoto Central Telephone Exchange and a new wing in the Shinpuhkan complex. Shops, restaurants, and the hotel are connected to the city through the development. A public path in a mixed-use hotel can lead to food or retail without giving visitors permission to occupy the residential part. Trace that route from the street lobby and draw the guest floor access separately, including where the person checking room access first becomes visible. Ace Hotel Kyoto, Eat + Drink Kengo Kuma and Associates, Shinpuhkan Ace Hotel Kyoto, 2020 Danielle Demetriou, Kengo Kuma’s Ace Hotel Kyoto opens in a converted telephone office, Wallpaper*, June 19, 2020

In a 2018 CoStar report, The Robey in Chicago used a second-floor host to direct visitors to its rooftop bar by elevator, while Hotel Emma in San Antonio used guest keycards for elevator access to selected areas. They are different operating responses, each in its own building. The decision depends on the section through the building. If the bar and hotel share the same elevator, write down which floors should respond to a visitor and where a guest gets help when a card fails. If the hotel has a separate bank, put the choice between elevators where a first-time operator or guest can read it quickly. CoStar, How Hoteliers Manage Limited Access to Public Spaces

Work through a return after midnight

After the bar closes, a member of the public may be leaving just as a registered guest returns from the street. A plan can show how both get through the lobby. Show the position of staff and the route to the public toilets. Decide whether the entrance remains staffed and how an arriving guest attracts attention with a case beside them. Record how staff admit a guest whose mobile key is unavailable. Coordinate this with accessibility and life-safety advisers for the jurisdiction, and check the controls against the required egress routes and fire operation before specifying hardware. US Access Board, 2010 ADA Standards, Chapter 4, Accessible Routes NYC Department of Buildings, 2022 NYC Building Code, Chapter 10

The Metropolitan Police’s Operation Makesafe guidance describes staff presence and key-based controls in the context of hotel safeguarding. Use the operating premise in a shift walk-through. Ask the night receptionist to admit a returning guest, refer a visitor to the bar, and respond to a guest in an elevator lobby while another person is waiting at the door. Any equipment purchased for that plan should have an identified point for staff override and a route the user can understand when the system changes state. Metropolitan Police, Operation Makesafe, Extended Guidance for Hotel Staff, 2024

Keep the emergency release and access permissions on separate schedules. New York City’s 2022 Building Code, §1010.1.9.9, addresses particular arrangements for electromagnetically locked egress doors, including in R-1 occupancies where applicable. It has a different purpose from room-floor credentials. Have the applicable technical team review the controlled thresholds for exit movement and alarm behavior. Show the front office where it can see a person turned back by a credential reader and what authority it has to help. NYC Department of Buildings, 2022 NYC Building Code, Chapter 10

Trace deliveries and contractor appointments on the night plan only where they actually happen. A delivery worker may need a different direction after the public bar closes. Give the person receiving them a clear encounter point with an intercom or sign at the entrance the courier is told to use. The instruction in the staff manual should match the building after the doors are locked.