A guest trying mobile or kiosk check-in should be able to see where to get help before starting. Make it possible to go directly to the elevator when the key has been issued and the hotel allows it. Someone whose ID still needs checking or whose key fails should know where to stop. Draw both routes and bring them together only at a place that can hold the people waiting.
Draw the successful transaction and the exception
Hilton’s Digital Key help says that guests “may need to stop at the front desk for identification purposes”. Other decisions depend on the hotel and booking. The design team can use the operator’s actual rules to list the moments where a guest is handed back to staff. Include a reservation made by somebody else, a phone with a depleted battery, and an issue with the room assignment. The queue forecast should cover that redirected traffic as well as guests who choose the staffed route. Hilton Help Center, Digital Key
A Cornell hospitality study by Tsz-Wai Liu and Gabriele Piccoli examined self-service kiosks at two hotel brands. The researchers did not find a gain in guests’ perception of speed and reported an adverse relationship between kiosk failures and willingness to return. The work concerns an earlier kind of self-service and does not measure today’s phones. It gives owners a reason to measure recovery. Record how long a guest waits between leaving a failed transaction and being helped, and how many times they have to give staff the same information. Tsz-Wai Liu and Gabriele Piccoli, Integrating Self-Service Kiosks in a Customer-Service System, 2010
William Speros’s report on citizenM Bowery shows a portrait collage behind the self-check-in kiosks. The busy background is also a locator for guests approaching the stations. Have the operator show where payment, identity checks, and key reissues will happen at its own property. A visible help position should be distinguishable from a line that has already formed at the kiosks. William Speros, citizenM Bowery, Hospitality Design, October 30, 2018
Xinzhi Xu and Christian Greiffenhagen used video to study automated hotel arrivals. Their account of outages and interrupted transactions documents staff stepping in, including during a system outage. Size the fallback for a group arriving when several people cannot use the machines at once. If the desk can help one at a time, set out where the next parties wait and where one can take a seat without losing their place. Xinzhi Xu and Christian Greiffenhagen, The disciplined customer, New Media & Society, 2024
Draw the help point with the equipment connected
The US Access Board’s ADA provisions for operable parts and reach ranges are relevant to covered components. Check the applicable requirements for the devices and project with the access adviser. For a kiosk, draw the clear floor space with a companion and a bag present. Check the screen’s angle and glare as someone approaches and whether payment and key pickup fit the same position. Where a device’s design excludes someone, the staffed alternative needs to handle the same transaction during the same hours. U.S. Access Board, 2010 ADA Standards, Chapter 3
For a web-based check-in, WCAG 2.2 addresses consistent placement of help and accessible authentication in its applicable criteria. Review the booking link, advance check-in instructions, and help page with the same team designing the on-site signs. Choose wording that names the place the guest will see. If the message tells a guest to find a mobile key station and the plan labels it reception, agree on the wording and the visible destination before commissioning the signs. Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.2, W3C Recommendation, December 2024 version
The hotel can take the instructions a guest receives and follow them along the actual route. A message promising direct room access should tell guests what to do if their phone cannot display a key. Place the staff station where a guest leaving the elevator can return to it without lining up at a separate door. On a small night shift, have the one employee call up a reservation and get a guest past the elevator with the exact staffing and opening hours used in the plan.