GOLEMArchitecture·Art·Design

06.f.3How can restaurant architecture accommodate different cultural expectations of privacy?

Diners need a degree of control over who can see, hear or approach their group, and the restaurant should be able to say what each seating choice offers. A restaurant can offer a position that is sheltered from view, an enclosed room that contains speech or a table where service approaches at agreed moments. Find out which of those conditions matters to the people the operator expects, for which activities. A household celebration, a business meeting and a quick meal alone can come with different expectations in the same neighbourhood.

Privacy can change during a visit

Irwin Altman's paper on privacy regulation distinguishes the effort to control access to oneself or a group from the arrangements people use to achieve it. Those arrangements vary across cultures and situations. The theory concerns how people control access. The design team can use it to specify a change over time. A group may wish to be visible when its guests arrive, reduce contact during a conversation and reopen the room for service. An operable door and a staff protocol can together accomplish something that a permanent opaque panel cannot. Irwin Altman, Privacy Regulation, Journal of Social Issues, 1977

In their restaurant table-spacing study, Robson and colleagues found that responses to proximity and seating varied with the meal people were considering. More than 1,000 US participants responded to written scenarios on the web. Closely spaced conditions prompted particular dislike when people considered a romantic occasion. These are preferences in the study's scenarios. Apply the method to particular occasions. Ask someone where they would take a meeting or bring relatives, using photographs of the same seat in both directions. Looking from the seat towards a partition emphasises enclosure. Looking from the entrance towards the seat can show whether the person arriving sees straight into it. Robson and colleagues, Consumers’ Responses to Table Spacing in Restaurants, 2011

What a partition can do

In Kyoto, Yuko Nagayama & Associates turned a former warehouse and part of a hotel into the restaurant IZAMA. Its drawings and published description show partitions in the hotel portion, including metal interpretations of bamboo screens and a paper-faced arched element. The metal screen can filter a view through it. The paper-faced plate changes a view around its edge. Both observations concern the published visual arrangement. An acoustic boundary needs a separate brief, including the times when doors open and the amount of speech the next table is meant to hear. ArchDaily, IZAMA by Yuko Nagayama & Associates, 2014

ICHIRAN uses side dividers and a curtain at the counter to control a different encounter. The guest selects details of the order on a form and can use a call button, as the operator's system guide explains. The enclosure and the order procedure work together at a scale of one person. A conventional restaurant with a different menu might give each party a discreet way to request service and a view of the room, and locate the service route away from the table to reduce the frequency of interruptions. ICHIRAN, System Guide

Cultural expectations can also concern who initiates an exchange. Where waiting to be called suits a private table, the route for bringing food should allow a moment for staff to pause, make eye contact or wait for a request. In a table-service restaurant that relies on seeing whether water or plates need attention, give staff an agreed view from a place where they are already working. Agree which occasions the arrangement should work for in consultation with actual diners. A screen stays in one place. The reservation policy and the way people are served can give the same position a different degree of control later in the evening.

For a more enclosed arrangement, give the prospective group enough information to understand how a closed door will operate. Guests who wish to be visible at first can receive their party without staff blocking the entrance. Once they sit, a short turn from the public route can keep the seated group out of view. A person coming out to use a toilet needs to be able to return without asking for assistance. A readable route and the ability to control contact can coexist with a reservation that limits who else enters the room.

The route a guest takes, the position where a server takes an order and the seat nearest the next party each offer a different view of the same layout. Check two stages with a door open, at first arrival and while the largest dish is delivered. If the booking promises discretion at those moments, let a host demonstrate how people will get in and where service stops. The part of the arrangement that depends on a person should be written into the booking and staffing plan.