GOLEMArchitecture·Art·Design

02.g.11How should a design team respond to conflicting accessibility feedback?

When users report different experiences, the design team can record each account and look at the conditions that produced it. Two people can use the same room and encounter different barriers. Ask what each person was trying to do, which part of the design affected them and whether the difficulty could be resolved by a change to the space, the way it operates or the information available.

Put the disagreement on the drawing. One visitor may need brighter light to read an object label. Another may find that the same light makes the display hard to approach. Mark the positions where people stood or sat, the direction of the light and the surfaces it illuminated. Test a local reading light, a different angle or a separate text at the same point on the route. Ask participants to try the alternatives and tell the design team what each change permits. Keeping the trial specific helps the team distinguish a preference from a barrier to using the exhibit.

The RIBA's Inclusive Design Overlay defines design-stage responsibilities and activities. Transport Scotland's research on inclusive design in town centres records designers' and other practitioners' perspectives on competing needs in street environments. Those accounts are useful when deciding who should take part in resolving a design issue. For a cultural interior, show the consequences of each option for the people who raised it, check the applicable local requirements and make the decision with the client and access specialist. RIBA, Inclusive Design Overlay Transport Scotland, Inclusive Design in Town Centres, Appendix D

Some changes can coexist. A visitor may choose between two lighting conditions or between a place near activity and a quieter one. In a single shared space, check that the options are available at comparable times and that people can find them. Agree who can make changes during operation and what happens if the mechanism or information fails. If the project has to choose one option, keep the reason, the remaining barrier and any provision for a further test in the decision record. Give the people who raised the issue a chance to review that account.

Bring the conflicting observations and current options to Ariel André and GOLEM. Commission a focused design trial that compares the consequences in use and gives the client something to decide before the tender drawings are issued.