A review after opening needs the people who use the building and the team responsible for keeping it open. Check whether people can carry out the activities promised in the brief, under the conditions in which those activities actually take place. Record what they encounter on the way, who has to intervene and what can be changed. Give each action an owner and arrange a second visit to see whether the change works.
Follow the same tasks under different conditions
A review can revisit a few complete journeys from the original brief. Follow someone finding a seat at a talk, going to the toilet during a workshop or using a staff entrance before opening. Observe a normal day and a busy event. At each point, note whether the issue is with the building, with the information supplied before the visit or with a decision made on the day. A bench moved for a reception can take away the only place to wait within sight of a workshop door. Record its location on the event plan so the next layout can be checked.
Disabled visitors and staff who use the building in different ways can help run the review. Ask people who abandoned a visit or who rarely come what happened at the point when they decided to leave. A low complaint count needs to be read alongside direct observation and interviews. Separate an obstacle requiring immediate action from a recurring issue that needs design work. Collect feedback in forms the participants can use and report the findings without identifying individuals.
Test the change
For a venue with several uses, revisit a junction at different hours. At the Diriyah Biennale Foundation Public Programs Building, Ariel André - GOLEM placed workshops, a library, a café and a lounge in an adapted warehouse. In a building with that mix, a useful evaluation might follow the route from the shared area to a workshop when a class is arriving, then observe the same route during a talk. The two visits can show whether a proposed change belongs to the signs, the layout of waiting furniture or the programme itself. Diriyah Public Programs Building
A first review date gives the operator a chance to ask the design team about the building while it is still available to help. Put the follow-up date and responsibility for corrections in the appointment. The Department for Education's Soft Landings Guide offers an example of aftercare and post-occupancy evaluation used to check performance against a brief. For a cultural venue, record the date and conditions of each observation and keep the revised plan with the evaluation. Department for Education, Soft Landings Guide
SceneHome’s interview with Ariel André documents the colour-coded rooms and communal sofa at Diriyah. Those decisions give an evaluation team two things it can check separately. Ask a first-time visitor to find a room, then observe whether the seating works as a waiting place when several activities start together. The interview establishes what was designed. The visit establishes how people use it. Serag Heiba, SceneHome
For an existing venue, ask GOLEM to compare the opening brief with observations of a real programme. Bring event plans, staff reports and a date when the team can return to see whether any change worked.